If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!
by Carma Dutra
Have you been wondering what your writing needs?
Are you talking to yourself… out loud?
Do you wonder what it would be like to talk to someone else about your writing?
Do you yearn for the passion of other writers?
If you answered Yes, you’re ready to join or create a writers’ critique group.
Critique members are supportive, critical, and attuned to the work and not the personality of an individual member. Also, they intend to publish their work.
You can find critique groups online through organizations such as the Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators (SCBWI), Children’s Writers Coaching Club (CWCC) or you can form a person-to-person group where you live. If there is no writing group in your local area, check with bookstores and libraries. Create flyers; post them in coffee shops and bookstores. Network with local organizations.
Here are 10 tips for a successful critique group:
1. Find a group with similar goals and focus. Is your group open to all genres or is it specific? Memoir? Do people want to publish? Explore character? Having similar goals and a focus will create commitment and synergy.
2. Limit the number of members. Four or five is a good starting place. If one person leaves the group, replace him/her with a new writer. Fill empty spots by invitation and agreement by the group. This builds trust and respect in your group.
3. Establish a time and day that is suitable to everyone. For example, one evening every two weeks or a weekend day. Twice a month is usually better than weekly because it gives the writers a chance to write and edit in between meetings.
4. Establish a meeting place that works for everyone. Find a coffee shop or meeting space that can accommodate the size of your group or take turns meeting at members’ homes.
5. Create a deadline for submitting work to each other by email. This way, every member should have time to read the work before the critique session.
6. Critique the writing, not the writer. Find what works and what is good. Be objective, as if the writer is absent.
Example critique: “There is a POV shift in this section…I want to know more…perhaps another word would work better here…”
Get the picture? Give the writer time to explain unanswered questions.
7. When receiving critiques…sit back and take notes. Be quiet. Let the questions and comments fly. Don’t throw heavy objects. Also, don’t spend time defending your work or explaining why you wrote things the way you did. Your writing needs to work on its own, without explanations.
8. Critiques must have a time limit. Calculate the critique time based on the length of the meeting and numbers in the group. If you have a large group you can divide up critiques every two weeks.
9. Don’t socialize too much. Your purpose is to get feedback about your work. Be reasonable. You can get to know each other in many other ways.
10. Most importantly, respect confidentiality. Make an agreement with the whole group. Don’t steal ideas, and don’t talk about the work outside the group except in general terms if necessary.
Follow these tips and soon you’ll be enjoying the support and constructive feedback that a strong writers’ critique group can provide.
********************
Carma Dutra is a children’s writer. She offers author interviews, book reviews, writing tips, and other information for fellow children writers at her blog.









If you’ve decided to make 2008 the year you finally become a published children’s author yourself, you’ll want to join the Children’s Writers’ Coaching Club to get the help you need to do that.
Learn the “tricks of the trade” to become a published children’s book author by joining the Children’s Writers’ Coaching Club here at the National Writing for Children Center.
This week’s practice writing assignment was to write a short, short story in The Core of Three. So we’ll be going over those, too.
Many aspiring children’s writers - and even published children’s writers - find critique groups to be helpful.